查看原文
其他

CityReads│Why did Shanghai become the key to modern China?

2014-12-19 Rhoads 城读
5
Why did Shanghai become the key to modern China?

This book traces how Shanghai grew from a regional port in pre-industrial China to one of the leading modern metropolises in the world between 1843 and 1943 under the western influence. It argues that Shanghai provides a key to the understanding of modern China.

Rhoads Murphey, 1953. Shanghai: key to modern China, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Shanghai and the pattern of its development between 1843 and 1943 have been modern China in microcosm. In the city China for the first time learned and absorbed the lessons of extrateerritoriality, gun-boat diplomacy, foreign "concessions", and the aggressive spirit of 19th century Europe. There more than anywhere else the two civilizations came together: the rational, legal-minded, scientific, industrialized, efficient, expansionist West, and traditional, intuitive, humanist, agrarian, inefficient, seclusionist China. The sequel, and China's response, began primarily in Shanghai, and then modern China was born. Shanghai provides a key to what has since happened and is still to happen in China.

The city of Shanghai, born out of Western commercial enterprise and organized in its economic life largely along Western lines, was in effect superimposed on a peasant civilization. On this agrarian base, it erected first a trade which reached to all parts of the globe, and subsequently a manufacturing complex which put it among the leading urban industrial centers of the world. Toward the close of the first century since its opening to foreign trade in 1843, Shanghai accounted for half of China's foreign trade and half of its mechanized factories. The city's four million people formed one of the first five or six metropolitan groupings in the world, and Shanghai was well over twice the size of each of its nearest urban rivals in China, Peking and Tientsin.

This book is divided into two parts. The first, “The Setting”, deals with population, site characteristics, locational qualities, historical development, and political characteristics, all in relation to China as a whole. The second part, “Key Functions”, is far more significant. Murphy presents an insightful analysis of the ways in which Shanghai has operated within the Chinese political economy. Its location at the mouth of the vast Yangtze basin and the associated convergence of river transport toward the city have made it both entrance and exit for Middle China, the most densely populated and productive part of China proper. The physical advantages of Shanghai’s location made it the major point of contact between China and the West. The most important thing about Shanghai was its relation to China; and that the city contained the seeds of great change for the entire country.

Shanghai before 1843

Chinese Shanghai had risen as the port of Suzhou, from a small fishing village at the junction of Suzhou Creek and the Huangpu River. When silting, and presumably advance of the coastline, made maritime access to Suzhou impossible by the 11th century A.D. Ships began to dock at Shanghai, or Hudu as it was then called and in 1075 an official was stationed there to administer the customs. In 1279 the town, now called Shanghai declared itself independent of Suzhou. It was however still too small in the 13th century to be mentioned by Marco Polo. The city walls were built in 1544 following the sacking and burning of the city in the preceding year by Japanese pirates.

Shanghai County


By the beginning of the 19th, Shanghai was the principal port of the Yangtze basin, and was also the center of the coastal trade between north and south China. Shanghai before 1843 had grown primarily on the trade of its immediate delta hinterland: tea, silk, and rice and on its key position in the coasting trade which enabled it to act as an entrepot and to distribute goods received by sea within the densely populated delta. But the wider water network, both sea and river, of which it stands at the focus was not fully exploited. It remained for foreign traders and foreign economic organization, implemented by the steamship, to realize the geographic potential of Shanghai’s location.

In 1812 the official gazetteer of Shanghai estimated the population of the county, which included an area of about 400 square miles, at 528,000. Despite its commercial prominence, it did not seriously rival the older delta cities in size because they were in varying degrees administrative centers, a function which Shanghai has always lacked beyond its own metropolitan limits. It was administration more than commerce that was the consistent basis of urban existence and growth in the bureaucratic framework of traditional China.

Politics and population

At Shanghai, there were three independent political units. First, the original Chinese city, which was governed by the local Chinese county authorities until 1928, when the Nationalist Government established the Municipality of Greater Shanghai, totaling 320 square miles, most of which remained open rural country. Second, the so-called International Settlement, which had originally been British and which was opened to all foreigners in 1854. This was the largest and most populous political unit, and it included the city's commercial core, most of its manufacturing, and most of its shipping frontage. Third, the French Settlement usually miscalled the "French Concession". The population of both foreign settlements was overwhelmingly Chinese.

Source:virtualshanghai.net

Several difficulties accounted for the inaccuracies of population estimation. First it was Shanghai’s role as a haven of security for Chinese (and, during the 1930s, foreign) refugees during periods of political unrest, and its subsequent loss of most of this floating population when order has been restored. The city has also contained a large but unmeasured population of homeless Chinese and of Chinese families living in boats moored on the numerous creeks which dissect the city.

An accurate census of the foreign residents in the foreign settlements was not taken until 1870s. It was not until 1928 that the Shanghai Municipal Council began a yearly census for the entire city.

Until 1895 Shanghai remained almost exclusively a trading city, with a consequent population which never exceeded half a million. Industrial development added to Shanghai’s population some three millions during the first world war. It is probable that the total population rose to well over four million by 1941 and that it dropped to the 1936 figure during the period of Japanese occupation after 1941. The influx of returning Chinese refugees beginning in 1945 probably boosted the population to its highest total, between five and a half and six million.

In 1936 the foreign total of 60,000 had as its most important constituents 20,000 Japanese, 15,000 Russians, 9,000 British, 5,000 Germans and Austrians, 4,000 Americans, and 2,500 French.

Shanghai remained a Chinese city, still politically dominated by the handful of foreigners, but economically more and more maintained by the Chinese.

Populationin major Chinese port cities in 1936


Source: estimatedby Lynne Pan






Site

Yangtze River is silt-laden and is extending its delta. The site of Shanghai would have been on the seacoast about 500 BC. Shanghai has served as Suzhou's port since about the 5th century.

The material on which Shanghai rests is totally unconsolidated and presents serious problems for building. An average vertical section shows silt from the surface to about 20 feet, sand to 300 feet, and gravel mixed with sand and silt to about 1000 feet, where some consolidated conglomerate is reached. These problems have been overcome, at considerable expense, by floating the taller buildings on concrete rafts in order to provide a stable foundation adequate to support structures which would otherwise sink into the alluvium.

The harbor

The trade of the Yangtze basin requires a major outlet to the sea, and Shanghai, despite its poor site, offers the only practicable deep-water harbor near the mouth of China's greatest trade highway, the Yangtze River. From 1920 to 1936 Shanghai remained 6th or 7th among world ports in terms of annual net registered tonnage entered and cleared.

Disadvantages as a harbor:

The tidal inflow from the Yangtze which brings in relatively fresher water also brings in and deposits large amounts of silt. Shanghai maintains its position as a port from the Yangtze estuary only by constant dredging.

On the outside of the sharp bend in the Whangpoo (Huangpu) at the mouth of Soochow (Suzhou) Creek the currents maintained a depth adequate for sailing ships of the 19th century, and in 1842 there was a channel in the Huangpu between Shanghai and the Yangtze estuary with a minimum navigable depth of about 15 feet. By 1905 silting had reduced this to 10 feet, and in that year dredging work was begun by the Huangpu Conservancy Board.

Shanghai in 1936 (the last year of regular dredging operations), was the shallowest as well as the most confined and awkward harbor among leading Far Eastern ports.

Advantages as a harbor:

Shanghai is the northernmost port on the China coast to be free from ice at all seasons in most years. This gives it an advantage over the two leading ports of north China.

Location 14 miles up the Huangpu gives the harbor protection from typhoons, which are a significant menace to shipping in all south China ports during late summer.

Fog adequate to delay shipping in the harbor is quite infrequent.

Shanghai is flat and it has a more favorable climate than rival south China ports.

To recap, the advantages of the city’s location have greatly outweighed the disadvantages of its site and have made extensive dredging worthwhile.

The growth of Shanghai must be regarded as an illustration of the extent to which the advantages of an exceptionally favorable location can overcome the disadvantages of an unfavorable site.

Location
Shanghai is great city primarily because it stands at the apex of the most fertile and populous area of comparable size anywhere in the world, the lower Yangtze basin. The river’s course is marked by successive clusters of settlement, terminating westward in the densely people Red Basin of Sichuan.

The Yangtze watershed totals 750,000,000 square miles, or half of China proper, and has a population of approximately 200,000,000. Of the other major cities of the lower Yangtze basin, Hangzhou, Suzhou, and Nanjing were all at one time imperial capitals, and all have remained important commercial and industrial centers. While all three of these cities were larger than Shanghai before the opening of China to foreign trade and to Western commercial exploitation, they were quickly outstripped by Shanghai under new economic conditions, where access by water to the entire Yangtze basin and to the major ocean lanes of world commerce gave it a decisive advantage.


The total of inland waterways navigable from Shanghai by junks at all seasons is nearly 30,000 miles. This transport network is reflected in the fact that Shanghai between 1865 and 1936 handled between 45 and 65 percent of the total foreign trade of China by value.


For the coasting trade it is a natural terminus. It was the division point between the carrying trade of junks from northern and southern ports, and that it acted as the leading entrepot on the China coast for the concentration and exchange of goods from the two major regions of China.


Shanghai’s orientation to the sea is almost equally favorable. It is located in a focal position for Far Eastern shipping, and it is in a median location between Atlantic Europe and America.


Midway on the China coast between north and south, Shanghai has the further double advantage of accessibility from the Chinese hinterland and nearness to Japan and the trans-Pacific trade. As Hugh Lindsay, leader of a commercial mission sent by the British East India Company, made a journey to Shanghai in 1832 and reported that Shanghai’s location had already made it a large trading city. “It is the seaport of the Yangtze River and the principal emporium of eastern Asia.”
Trade

The three great trade commodities at the first beginning of treaty ports era were tea, silk, and opium, and for all of them Shanghai was advantageously located. In 1846, 16 percent of China’s export trade passed through the city, and by 1861 its share was 50 percent.


It was the trade in tea and silk until the close of the 19th century that contributed to the commercial growth of Shanghai. Opium played as great if not a greater part in Shanghai’s rise than did tea or silk, and that it continued to stimulate the growth and concentration of capital and commercial activity in the city long after tea and silk had lost their commanding positions.


Opium was not introduced into China by the Europeans. It had been consumed domestically, from both domestic and foreign sources, since at least the early 18th century, and the first Imperial Edict against the import and smoking of opium was issued in 1729. Though opium was no innovation of the Europeans, it is true that it was they who first organized its import on a large scale.


Shanghai’s key role in this process is evident from its command of the Yangtze trade artery, and it was the principal market for the distribution of both imported and domestic opium. Concentration at Shanghai played an important part in the process of capital accumulation in the city, which was in turn a significant advantage in its continuing acquisition of commercial (and later industrial) dominance.


The import of opium into China was legally abolished in 1917 by the terms of an international convention, and it disappeared from customs figures at that time. But it was clearly still a powerful generator of capital and trade in the Shanghai of the 1930s. The relative decline in opium was not due to the prohibition of its import as much as to the spread of opium cultivation in China.


The primacy of Shanghai in both the foreign and domestic trade of China was well established by at least 1865 and this primacy was never seriously threatened before 1937. Shanghai’s share of China’s overseas commerce consistently totaled about one half from the opening of the Yangtze to foreign trade until the outbreak of full-scale hostilities with Japan.



The export of tea and silk and the import of opium and cotton textiles dominate the greater half of the period since 1850 in Shanghai’s, as in China’s foreign trade. Despite Shanghai’s key location for the trade in both tea and silks, however, the city’s overseas imports exceeded its overseas exports in value in every year save two from 1864 to 1936.


China’s monopolies of the tea and silk trade disappeared by about the end of 19th century. Foreign trade goods diversified: vegetable oils, hides, skins and bristles, eggs and fibers. Agricultural and animal products (or raw materials in general) remained the majority of Shanghai’s exports through 1930, but their prominence continued to decrease after 1890 as textiles and other manufacturing goods increased in importance. Exports of miscellaneous manufactures finally exceeded exports of miscellaneous raw materials in 1930.


In sum, between 1860 and 1930, Shanghai, as the primary focus, first of the commercialization of Chinese economy, and later of its industrialization, changed in its import trade from a position primarily as distributor of foreign consumption goods to its tributary area of the Yangtze basin to one primarily as consumer and distributor of foreign capital goods and industrial raw materials, while in its export trade it changed from the market for overseas shipments of the “noble articles” of tea and silk to the market for overseas shipments of the more mundane products of the Yangtze basin as a whole and of the goods produced by the city’s own industry.
Manufacturing

Shanghai is not only the primary industrial center of China proper, but has a virtual monopoly of large-scale manufacturing enterprises in nearly every field. Two factors are principally responsible for this concentration. First, Shanghai and its trading area represent the largest market in China; and second, despite the local absence of most industrial raw materials, cheap transportation makes it possible for Shanghai industry to produce competitively.


Shanghai accounted for about half of the country’s large-scale western-type industrial production. It was estimated that 43 percent of China’s industrial workers in modern manufacturing were employed in Shanghai, and the city accounted for 51 percent of the value of China’s industrial production.Textile manufacturing was the leading industry in Shanghai in the period 1920-1936. Food industries were second. Clothing industries ranked third, leather and rubber goods fourth, paper and printing fifth, chemical industries sixth and manufacture of machinery seventh. Manufacturing came relatively late in the development of modern Shanghai, and has always been subordinate to the city’s trading function
How Shanghai is fed?

Crop yields in the fertile triangle are among the highest in China. Rice is the basic food commodity for Shanghai. The Shanghai rice merchants divide their main supply areas into three categories: a. local rice (roughly from within a 75-mile radius); b. out-province rice (from Anhui, Jiangxi, Zhejiang, Jiangsu and Hunan); c. foreign rice (from the Indo-Chinese peninsula, mainly ex-Saigon, but including small amounts from Bankok and Rangoon).


The largest part of the rice supply of Shanghai comes from within a radius of approximately 75 miles and moves to city largely by water transportation. Foreign rice is also ordered when other natural or threatened hiatuses occur in the local supply due to weather, civil unrest, short supply in storage, or price stoppages.
Conclusion

In the long run, Shanghai’s economic growth will depend on a restoration of free access by sea to the whole of East Asia and to the rest of the world.


The geographic logic of the city's economic leadership is likely to prove more powerful and more convincing than any political argument. Great cities do not arise by accident, and they are not destroyed by whim. The geographic facts which have made Shanghai will prosper in the future once peace has been restored in East Asia.
Follow us!
"CityReads", a subscription account on WeChat, posts our notes on city reads weekly. Please follow us by searching "CityReads" or scanning the QR code below:
QR code


您可能也对以下帖子感兴趣

文章有问题?点此查看未经处理的缓存