其他

你永远不知道自己有多恶!

2017-06-11 阅尽天下无数沧桑
精彩内容


揭黑幕


揭开不为人知的黑幕


↑↑↑长按,选择识别图中二维码关注



来源:腾讯网


1971年,菲利普·津巴多(Philip Zimbardo)的斯坦福大学教授启动了一项社会心理学实验,叫“斯坦福监狱实验”Stanford Prison Experiment,实验的目的是想看看人在社会环境里的反应。


We wanted to see what the psychological effects were of becoming a prisoner or prison guard. To do this, we decided to set up a simulated prison and then carefully note the effects of this institution on the behavior of all those within its walls.


他以每天15美金的报酬招募愿意参加实验的志愿者,当时有近百人前来报名,基本都是美国的大学生,最后通过心理测试,选定了24名“心理健康,没有疾病”的学生,参加一个为期两周的监狱模拟实验。


这些学生一开始只是为了好玩或者赚点零花钱而加入的,但是他们不知道,这次看似好玩的实验,将会成为他们终生挥之不去的梦魇……


We began with nine guards and nine prisoners in our jail. Three guards worked each of three eight-hour shifts, while three prisoners occupied each of the three barren cells around the clock. 


这些学生被随机地分成了两组,9名学生扮演囚犯,9名学生扮演看守,其他6人替补,津巴多教授本人扮演监狱长。当时很多志愿者都表示他们更愿意饰演囚犯,认为这更有挑战性,可以从中学到更多东西。


为了更逼真地模拟监狱场景,他们将斯坦福大学的地下室改造成了一个监狱实验室,里面的一切设置都跟监狱一模一样。


实验组还和加州警方合作,用真警车去扮演“囚犯”的9个人家里把他们铐走,给他们穿上囚服,带上牛皮纸头套,给他们安上抢劫盗窃等罪名……



在邻居的震惊中,这9名“囚犯”被带到了斯坦福实验“监狱”。


而扮演“看守”的9名学生,也都穿上了警服,配上警棍,增加权威性。


All guards were dressed in identical uniforms of khaki, and they carried a whistle around their neck and a billy club borrowed from the police. Guards also wore special sun-glasses,an idea I borrowed from the movie Cool Hand Luke. Mirror sunglasses prevented anyone from seeing their eyes or reading their emotions, and thus helped to further promote their anonymity. 



在实验开始前,所有人都签订了协议。“囚犯”被告知了可能会有人权侵犯行为,也都有心理准备。“看守”拥有预警的所有权力。全程只有一个“监控者”,来提醒大家的行为,防止失控造成危险。



就这样,实验开始了!


实验第一天,一切都按照真实监狱的流程来走:


“囚犯”被“看守”裸身检查并消毒。


进行到第二天,实验开始失控了!


“囚犯”们很不严肃,因为感到无聊,居然开始造反,他们集结在一个牢房,撕掉身上的编号牌,拒绝服从命令,并且说话挑衅狱警。。


而“看守”们也完全不知所措。对此,扮演“监狱长”的津巴多教授要求他们行驶权力,采取措施维持监狱的秩序。



于是“看守”们开始采取惩罚措施:


罚“囚犯”做俯卧撑....


脱光衣服,关禁闭.....


没收枕头和被褥....


强迫“囚犯”用手清洗马桶....


剥夺“囚犯”的睡眠....


剥夺“囚犯”的姓名,只用犯人编号来称呼他们……


“看守”们的学习能力很强,惩罚方式也越来越离谱。他们还采用了心理上的分化策略:服从管理的囚犯会得到特权,被分到更好的牢房和更好的伙食。



表现不好的“囚犯”,则被关禁闭,大小便也没人清理,环境变得越来越糟糕......慢慢的,很多人学会了服从!



然后,就有“囚犯”受不住虐待精神崩溃了……


编号为8612的“犯人”因为在之前带领“囚犯”们反抗“狱警”的管理,而受到了“狱警”们的格外『关照』…


最终他因为忍受不了巨大的精神压力,而产生了种种精神崩溃的症状,他开始歇斯底里地大哭、咒骂,并且要求退出……


最后,他们直到8612向其他“囚犯”们散布实验无法终结的消息,并开始完全失控,才决定放他离开。


During the next count, Prisoner #8612 told other prisoners, "You can't leave. You can't quit." That sent a chilling message and heightened their sense of really being imprisoned. #8612 then began to act "crazy," to scream, to curse, to go into a rage that seemed out of control. It took quite a while before we became convinced that he was really suffering and that we had to release him.



另一名“囚犯”819也出现了情绪失控,食不下咽。实验小组无奈只好打算放他走。这时别的囚犯居然开始议论:“819是个窝囊废!”“819真没用,还拖累我们!”


听到这些议论的819崩溃大哭,实验小组让他离开时,他竟然哭着拒绝了,还要回去向别人证明他不是一个窝囊废。


这时教授告诉他,你不是819,你不是一个囚徒,你的名字是xxx。听了这番话,这名志愿者才慢慢回过神来,离开了模拟监狱。


he said he could not leave because the others had labeled him a bad prisoner. Even though he was feeling sick, he wanted to go back and prove he was not a bad prisoner.

At that point I said, "Listen, you are not #819. You are [his name], and my name is Dr. Zimbardo. I am a psychologist, not a prison superintendent, and this is not a real prison. This is just an experiment, and those are students, not prisoners, just like you. Let's go."


实验进行到这里,所有人都被深深困在了这个实验里,无法自拔!


这群原本心理正常的大学生,都已经不知不觉接受了自己的定位:有的变成了施虐成瘾的狱警,有的变成了自怜自哀的囚犯。。


而此时的实验主持者津巴多教授的心理也发生了变化,他将自己带入到『监狱长』的角色之中。在后来的回忆中,教授说,他当时想的不是学术研究,而是如何收拾“囚犯”,他差不多将接受实验的志愿者们的心理健康置之度外了,一心只想着如何把这个游戏玩下去。


实验进行到第六天的时候,现场来了一位探访者,她被现场“看守”们的暴行和“囚犯”们的处境震惊了!


"It's terrible what you are doing to these boys!" Out of 50 or more outsiders who had seen our prison, she was the only one who ever questioned its morality. Once she countered the power of the situation, however, it became clear that the study should be ended.

And so, after only six days, our planned two-week prison simulation was called off.


这个实验提前终结了……


这个实验当时备受争议,在全世界范围内产生了巨大反响,成为社会心理学的经典案例,其中揭示的道理令人细思恐极……


好人与坏人的界限完全由拥有绝对权力的实验设计者决定。坏人(囚犯)被看做败类人渣,不配被当做人来看待。而好人(看守)则被授予武器和权力,“一旦你穿上制服,就好像开始扮演一个角色,你不再是你自己,你的所作所为要与这身制服所代表的职责相匹配。”


而人们也终于开始正视环境可以改变人的性格和行为:也许善恶并没有界限,只看你处于什么样的环境!


这个实验还被翻拍成了电影《斯坦福监狱实验》,揭示了很多社会和人性问题,让众人哗然和反思......


https://v.qq.com/txp/iframe/player.html?vid=n0016q5nkzh&width=500&height=375&auto=0


也许人性本恶,我们都是自身经历的囚徒。(we are prisoner of our own experience.)

您可能也对以下帖子感兴趣

文章有问题?点此查看未经处理的缓存