涉外商事案件汇编 | 法宝双语案例

北大法律信息网 2021-09-21

目录

Contents

1. 莱贝托股份有限公司诉国家工商行政管理总局商标评审委员会商标申请驳回复审行政纠纷再审案

Laibeituo Co., Ltd. v. Trademark Review and Adjudication Board of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce (retrial case of administrative dispute over the review of the rejection of application for trademark registration)

2. 吉美投资有限公司与河南鹰城集团有限公司等股权转让纠纷上诉案

Jimmy Investment Co., Ltd. v. Henan Yingcheng Group Co., Ltd. et al. (appeal case of dispute over transfer of equity)

3. 德国赛锡科技有限公司与赛锡科技（保定）有限公司与英利能源（中国）有限公司等加工合同纠纷上诉案

SIC Processing GmbH & SiC Processing (Baoding) Co., Ltd. v. Yingli Solar (China) Co., Ltd et al. (appeal case regarding processing contract)

一、莱贝托股份有限公司诉国家工商行政管理总局商标评审委员会商标申请驳回复审行政纠纷再审案

Laibeituo Co., Ltd. v. Trademark Review and Adjudication Board of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce (retrial case of administrative dispute over the review of the rejection of application for trademark registration)

【裁判要旨】

根据商标法规定，申请注册的商标，在同一种商品或者类似商品上已经注册的或者初步审定的商标相同或者近似的，由商标局驳回申请。实践中，引证商标已被商标评审委员会裁定不予核准注册，其应为已经注册或初步审定的商标，不构成申请商标注册的权利障碍。

[Judgment Abstract]

According to the provisions of the Trademark Law, when registration of a trademark is applied for, and such trademark is the same or similar to the trademark of another party, which has been registered or preliminarily approved for use on the same or similar goods, the Trademark Office shall reject the application. In practice, a reference trademark which has been disapproved for registration by the Trademark Review and the Adjudication Board should be a registered or preliminary approved trademark, therefore does not constitute a barrier to the right to apply for trademark registration.

【法宝引证码】CLI.C.9482837

[CLI Code] CLI.C.9482837(EN)

二、吉美投资有限公司与河南鹰城集团有限公司等股权转让纠纷上诉案

Jimmy Investment Co., Ltd. v. Henan Yingcheng Group Co., Ltd. et al. (appeal case of dispute over transfer of equity)

【裁判摘要】

外资审批制度改革后，对外商投资准入特别管理措施以外的外商投资企业的设立、变更，由行政审批制转为适用备案管理制，备案不影响合同生效。案涉股权转让合同订立之后还未经审批，在其履行期间外资审批制度改革实施，应依新法认定合同有效。

[Judgment Abstract]

Following the reform of the foreign investment examination and approval system, the establishment and change of foreign-funded enterprises other than the special administrative measures for foreign investment access will be changed from the administrative examination and approval system to the record management system. The record will not affect the validity of the contract. After being concluded, the equity transfer contract involved in this case has not been examined and approved. During the implementation period, the foreign investment examination and approval system has been reformed and implemented, therefore, the contract shall be determined as valid in accordance with the new laws.

【法宝引证码】CLI.C.10790462

[CLI Code] CLI.C.10790462(EN)

三、德国赛锡科技有限公司与赛锡科技（保定）有限公司与英利能源（中国）有限公司等加工合同纠纷上诉案

SIC Processing GmbH & SiC Processing (Baoding) Co., Ltd. v. Yingli Solar (China) Co., Ltd et al. (appeal case regarding processing contract)

【裁判要旨】

合同违约金性质为补偿性质，应当与合同违约造成的实际损失相当。具体案件中，一方当事人违约，应当依据合同约定的违约条款承担相应违约责任，但双方约定的违约金过分高于所造成损失的，法院应当根据当事人请求，结合案件的实际损失、合同履行情况、当事人过错程度及预期利益等因素，将违约金酌情予以调减。

[Judgment Abstract]

Contract liquidated damages are compensatory in nature, and therefore should be comparable to the actual losses caused by the breach of contract. In a specific case, if a party breaches the contract, they shall bear the corresponding liability for breach of contract in accordance with the breach clauses stipulated in the contract. However, if the contractual penalty agreed by the two parties is excessively higher than the actual losses, the court shall adjust or reduce the liquidated damages as appropriate, at the request of the parties, and in light of the actual losses in the case, the contract performance, the extent of the parties' faults and expected benefits, as well as other factors.

【法宝引证码】CLI.C.10804102

[CLI Code] CLI.C.10804102(EN)

-END-

责任编辑 | 郭书羽

稿件来源 | 北大法宝英文编辑组（Mani）

审核人员 | 张文硕

更多精彩，请点击菜单栏“法宝盘点-法宝原创-双语新闻”：

▼往期精彩回顾▼